The Pizza Heist

Category: Pizza restaurant in Lancaster, New York

Address: 231 Aurora St, Lancaster, NY 14086, USA

Phone: +17166811111

Opening hours

Sunday: 10AM–9PM

Monday: 10AM–9PM

Tuesday: 10AM–9PM

Wednesday: 10AM–9PM

Thursday: 10AM–9PM

Friday: 10AM–9PM

Saturday: 10AM–9PM

Reviews

S W

Jul 5, 2022

Ordered from here twice just moved to the area so we keep trying places. The Buffalo wings were gross, not crispy like i asked for and hot. These were dry like they ran out of sauce, and the pizza was meh but my son ate it. I called to find out if the wings were normally like this mgr said no and here is a$10 credit to try us again. Ordered a pizza again thought I'd give them another chance but wings from the place across the street as their wings are ALWAYS on point. Opened the pizza to find only 3/4 has cheese, not baked completely and way to much sauce causing whatever bit of cheese on the pie to slide off in the box. Called to complain said they would bring a new pizza in an hour. An hour!! Forgetaboutit i will patronize a better place even if it costs twice as much. The girl.slammed the phone after i said i was shocked that a.pizza like this could be considerably sold and served. All I can say is lesson learned read reviews 1st.

Nicole Kisiel

Jul 1, 2022

We have been ordering regularly from the Pizza heist probably since they opened and have always been happy with what we have received. They are a small mom and pop business family owned and we’re happy to have them in the neighborhood. Pizza 👌 My daughter loves the chicken fingers Steak hoagie on point.

Donna Kufel

May 28, 2022

Always the best pizza, wings ad subs! I have to have the steak hoagie whenever I come to town… if you like some zest, add the cherry peppers!!!! Yum!!!!!

Sheila Mamon

Mar 21, 2022

I ordered a pizza & boneless wings combo The wings were great, I wish I could say the same for the pizza, so disappointed.... The pie was part thick & part thin crust, the sauce and cheese were so uneven that some parts were swimming in sauce and cheese while other parts barely had either. The fact that this business considers this acceptable to sell to a customer is quite concerning.....

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.

Questions & Answers

Are you open tomorrow on the 4th?

Kathy Franger | Jul 3, 2021
David Krug | Jul 4, 2021

No they close early on the 3rd and reopen on the 5th

Thanks! Your answer is awaiting moderation.

Thanks! Your question is awaiting moderation.

Related Places