NY Pizzeria By The Slice

Luis Quezada

The service here is phenomenal. The pizza is delicious and hot out of the oven. It's hard to beat the price

Jessica Tounzen

I decided to give their white pizza a try after reading all the rave reviews for it. I’ve eaten many white pizzas and I’m sad to say theirs does not even compare. First, the flavor was incredibly bland. Aside from the super-sweet ricotta, there was basically no flavor. Next, the price. $29 for a medium white pizza? Yikes. I added bacon and fresh basil and did not see or taste ANY basil on the pizza. I thought the high price would be an indicator of quality. Boy, was I wrong. And finally, the presentation. As I mentioned, I requested to add bacon, thinking that, like most pizza places, the bacon would be chopped up. Nope. When I opened the box there were actual slices of bacon. And not even the good stuff - the cheap, greasy, off-brand kind of bacon. To top it off, the staff were not friendly at all, and after I gave a 15% tip, my mediocre white pie with its lack of fresh basil and its cheap bacon strips came out to $43. Worst part is that I didn’t ask for a receipt, so I probably couldn’t get my money back even if I wanted to. I ate three and a half slices just in an attempt to get some of my money’s worth. The rest is going in the trash, and I HATE wasting food. Don’t waste your money here. There are definitely better pizzas to be had in San Diego; this ain’t it.

Rick Howrey

I'm usually not a big fan of New York style pizza but I wanted to try this place out. It actually was pretty good. Lots of meat on the meat pizza and the 5 cheese pizza had a good cheese flavor.

Christopher Lieberman

Amazing pizza, even by the slice! Homemade dough, quality toppings, excellent cheese, amazing sauce, and best of all they are competitively priced. Update: This pizza place is wonderful for dine in, however, there is a caveat to placing a delivery order. I have experienced items such as the salad will occasionally be disregarded. Recently a new hire delivered this pie to me. Now I am not going to rant straight into a negative tangent like you normally see with reviews. I am just reporting to consumers my own personal experience. Perhaps this establishment was having a bad night. We all are human after all, but part of making mistakes is having a clearly decisive plan of action in order to resolve the issue. I personally didn't see such a task being executed. Instead, it seemed like replacing my pizza was brandished as a free pizza delivered to me at no charge... The pictures of the pizza have been updated right next to the individual slices that I took during my walk-in visit.