Brewster's Italian Cafe

Povilas Kazlauskas

Hey guys, not sure if it's today or something changed in the kitchen. We ordered bruschetta which was delicious, but I believe bread still has to be toasted and soft, this time it felt we baiting a rock. Soup was great, no comments here. But I had really bad experience we chicken Alfredo. When I got I noticed the chicken pieces were huge. Then I took a bite and I felt that chicken is not even cooked properly. I asked to bring me cooked better, I got it new one and still found red spots in chicken meat which means was not properly cooked and also felt that pasta also was cooked fully. Alfredo sauce barely felt the taste. I did ordered this one last year and had no complaints and I was really happy with this place, I drove here with my girlfriend from Chicago to repeat experience and it was not that what we got it last year. Prices are higher quality is poorer. So I'll give you still few stars , drinks were good and soup was good.

Elizabeth Mendez

By far the BEST dinner we had in New Buffalo. The service was great and the drinks were delicious and we had the pride pizza which was surprisingly delicious!!! The dessert was fantastic as well. All around a great dining experience.

Chuck Losch

Fantastic service, delicious food, lovely outdoor patio with enough distance to feel comfortable. We got the special dinner for two. Great value but more than we could eat. Picked a salad, shared a flat bread pizza appetizer, shared the fantastic meatballs (4) and spaghetti, finally a choice of cookies and coffee. We got our dessert to go with iced coffee since it was a warm evening and we definitely needed to walk. Brenna was our server with a new person shadowing her. I forgot her name but she helped make our 45 anniversary dinner enjoyable.

chad svastisalee

You want desserts... you can't handle the desserts at Brewster's Italian Cafe. Indulgent, decadent and devine. Wait staff is attentive, friendly and quick. We visited on recommendation for dessert and was not disappointed. Standard entree and dessert menu rocks. We ordered creme brulee along with a chocolate decadent and had enough to take home. The mocha latte and Traverse City Whiskey are must haves. We highly recommend Brewster's Italian Cafe for family dining as the menu, service and tables are outstanding.