Ye Olde Fish House

John Gilgrist

Fish was excellent, meaty, lightly breaded and not greasy. Reasonable price and clean environment with friendly service. Sugar cream pie & coconut cream pie delicious. You have to eat here. Drove from Indy South side.

Reyanna Jackson

Always amazing food and friendly service. Definitely the best fried fish around. They have great sides too! Being someone who regularly gets discriminated against for being heavily tattooed (I'm a tattoo artist) and wild hair, it's definitely refreshing and a breath of comfort walking in here and them treating everyone with patience and smiles. You guys are awesome. Thank you for being pleasant humans 🥰 My ONLY complaint is that I cannot take my paraplegic sibling with me because this building is not wheelchair accessible.

Ian Van Camp

People always complain about local places with good food and service disappearing, well make sure that doesn't happen and support Ye Olde Fish House. Our first visit was great, super friendly, hot crispy fish sandwiches, the best fried taters we've had since Grandma got out the cast iron and a gooey slice of pecan pie. We could've easily spent more at a fast food place and not have had half as good a time.

Jessica

This is a picture of half of the platter special. You get 3-4 pieces of fish, a side & a drink. It’s not a bad deal for $10 and the man that was working the counter was very friendly. I only gave it 3 stars because the fish was not hot, not even warm, more like room temperature. It lacked in seasoning. I got the potatoes and they were ok but also lacked in seasoning. The sweet tea was perfect, tasted fresh brewed with just the right amount of sweet. I might give it one more try and have the tenderloin next time, but only because of the other good reviews and the super friendly staff.