Arthur's Supper Club

Madison Beck

New York strip was underwhelming; do not recommend Parmesan Crusted add on. It was basically a handful shredded Parmesan broiled on top. Walleye was huge but had no flavor and was full of bones. Salad bar was nice but small. Arthur old fashion and Wisconsin old fashion tasted very similar. Better off just ordering a generic brandy or whiskey old fashion how you like it not worth the up charge of the “specialty drink”.

Em Delta

Great food. Usual supper club feel. Bread, salad bar, soup bar. Prime ribs is awesome. Fantastic deserts. The Wisconsin old fashioned was on point

Sharon Cunz

Omg this is probably the best place I have ever ate at ! Everything was good we had prime rib buffet, it had all different meats , steamed vegetables, baked potatoes, mashed & gravy, shrimp so much food just in the buffet , give huge pieces of prime rib , and you can choose if you want it medium rare, and we had dessert , also included a salad bar , if you don't like prime rib , they have burgers, steaks, chicken, lobster you name it . Prices are very reasonable for all the good they give you !! Make reservations!!

Lori Meador

Our 1st time there. Staff was friendly and efficient. The building is quite unique and way bigger than it appears from the road. The food we had (filet and shrimp for my husband and I had the twin lobster tails) was good but I expected more for the price. Filet was tender enough but lacked some in flavor. My lobster tails were very small and a little chewy. Not so sweet. Don't get this wrong, it was good. Just not excellent 😕