Mellow Mushroom New Albany

Brad Oyer

First of all, we love mellow mushroom. I hope this visit was an anomaly. Also, the manager did what he could to make things right. My advice: 1) make absolutely sure your server knows exactly what ordered. 2) check with the server often while waiting for your food. 3) keep an eye on the kitchen, they appear to have some sub par kitchen staff. All in all, the food was good. If you go, be vigilant.

Joshua Fields

Mellow Mushroom has a fantastic selection of pizza to choose from. I got Might Meaty, Pacific Rim, and Koenig Karma and all were delicious. Buffalo dip is a must try, and the pretzel bites are very good. Service was a little slow during a busy hour, but the quality of service made up for it. Overall great pizza, experience, and would recommend to anybody!

Tim Kuebler

This was a full salad according to the New Albany Mellow Mushroom location. About three pieces of lettuce and the bowl 80% empty. My wife's spinach salad was no more full than this as well. I guess this is how they are saving money in the era of record setting inflation. Passing their "savings" onto the customer.

G Faustus

We went to a family lunch here for the first time for all of us. We ordered two appetizers, the Cloud Nine wings and the avocado smash with bruschetta and toast points. The wings were twice baked, now that being said, they were amazing. The sauce of garlic parm was thick and delicious, parmesan cheese coated everything. The only way they would have better is to be properly fried. The avocado smash was the favorite. The toast points were on punto. The avocado smeared over the buttery toast and topped with bruschetta definitely warmed up the appetite. For our pizza we tried the Havana Affair. It was truly a uniqur experience. The crust was a fresher, crispy, chewy ny style, but better. The toppings were amazing and created a taste we have never had before. There was jerk chicken, salami, diced pickles, two kinds of cheese and a mayo mustard drizzle over the top. Everyone of us loved it. My oldest cried eating it, said it was beautiful. We will definitely be back. Trying the hummus appetizer and getting a half mushroom special with half meats next time. Cannot wait.