Sue's Little Pizza Shop

Bryon Gross

We are blessed with great pizza, subs and wings in Western New York. However, Sue's is a special place. Her food is that level is above the mainstream. An awesome independent woman owned business.

Luke Wisecup

I love little Sue's. Great people amazing food and they call me by name. Great small town pizza shop 10/10 do reccomend

Linda Kennedy

Recent new customer and I will be a faithful one for years to come. I won’t be getting my pizza, wings, subs, or mac salad anywhere else in this area because Sue’s food is absolutely delicious. The cheese pizza reminded me of the same pizza I had in Italy! So fresh and tasty, outstanding real crust, a good bite and crunchy edges, like it just came out of a hearth oven in Naples. The wings were perfect extra crispy, yet still plump and juicy. Turkey sub was loaded with generous fresh turkey and fillings, and the mac salad recipe was so good, I ate the whole side that could have served four people! Each time I’ll try something new on the menu. Don’t bother with a factory chain place (you know which ones), get real homemade food at Sue’s Little Pizza Shop in Ontario. I come to Sue’s from Webster and it’s worth every yummy bite.

Nathan Bantle

It definitely is a little pizza shop as the dining room seats only about 12 people. I give these guys props for having a really good customer service. I was really skeptical about the price so I probably asked three or four times for them to recalculate the price and they were really kind and did it each time. I ended up calculating the price myself and found they were right the whole time! The wings were crispy and good. The pizza was creatively green which was a nice touch but lacked a bit on the flavor side of things. I might try again but it’s a little bit expensive and the food didn’t match the price. The toppings were generous which is also a plus. In my personal opinion it’s the sauce they need to rethink.