I had been around 10:30Pm to pickup the birthday cake and there wasn't queue. So better to go in weekdays after 10. Its open till 12Am.
I was there 3pm on a weekday after noon and it wasn't bad. Personally I wouldnt recommend going at all, not that great, Eileen's cheese cake is a lot better choice.
I visited at 6 on a weekday. No lines at all but general case was almost empty. Do not waste your money on the prepackaged stuff. Doesmt seem to be the same quality
I went during a weekday around 11am and no lines
No line at 7p during our weekday visit.
When we were there during the week the line was decent size but it moved very quickly.
Although the lines are long, they move very fast!!
I went on a Friday around 12:30-1PM and the line was only about a 10 minute wait.
Thanks! Your answer is awaiting moderation.