The Pocono moonshiner room would be my pick for the next level and your next visit. The curse of the pharo is rumored to be pretty hard to beat.. I can't wait until it and the Mad Hatter are available for booking.
I did the mooshiner room with my wife and daughter. It was our first time ever in an escape room. We didn't solve the room, but we were very close. I would highly recommend the moonshiner room. I probably wasted alot of time reading too far into clues we found, being amazed by the attention to detail, and engineering that went into it. I can't wait to go back. The owners are such nice people.
The moonshiners room is absolutely amazing, also it is the next step up difficulty wise after the mad scientist room.
Thanks! Your answer is awaiting moderation.