Is this the type of place you need to arrive early to get the best selection or will we be okay toward the end of the day?

You don't have to race it's peaceful, fresh and just enough space for everyone

Back in the Day does their best to restock during the day. There is usually a line, so be patient. But it is worth it. Especially if you are a visitor to the area, and won't be able to enjoy often. The Miss Hannah cookies are to die for and so was my chicken salad sandwich. And my mini cupcakes and just about everything else i have eaten their. I'm lucky to live near by, so I am able to enjoy often.

YES especially during holidays

Yea

Yes, arriving earlier is best for better quality and variety. It's generally a good idea to visit bakery's as early as feasible because the baked goods are at their freshest. Partially at places like this that are franchised like Panera or something.

Yes sir, get there early. Everything looked delicious, tho.

Yes definitely lol