All is possible..pickup at and return to another location
I rented in Toronto and returned it in Buffalo, no problem. I called Alamo first and she told me that if the app I was using to schedule my rental accepted the pick up point and drop off point, I could do it. Maybe just make sure you have the rental papers handy when going through customs. Call Alamo and ask if you want to be sure.
Thanks! Your answer is awaiting moderation.