Is this place overpriced or am I out of touch? I’ve went other places around here and they are all less expensive for a better experience/more ice cream and toppings

For one thing, it's frozen custard. You can get five scoops for $4. It's adding the toppings that add to it. I think the prices are reasonable compared to other top-notch ice cream places.

You get what you pay for

It's priced okay. I agree that if you add multiple toppings. The prices skyrocket. If you keep it simple you'll be good.