Sally's Apizza, also on Wooster Street, is most definitely Pepe's competitor. Many people say that Modern Apizza, on State Street, is as good. I've always preferred Pepe's. It's a tradition to get Pepe's then walk to Libby's for an Italian Ice, since childhood. That's probably where my preference originated. The Mashed Potato pie at Bar, in New Haven, is phenomenal. Marino's in West Haven has been a long time favorite as well. 🍕😋
Sallys down the street.
Thanks! Your answer is awaiting moderation.