You may be able to go to Sam's club.com and request a replacement there. Otherwise, you can do it in-store at the customer service area.
The best when you get the new one you connected with the app so you dont have to carry the physical one any more. I shop, scan with the app, pay on the app and just show the QR code on my phone and walk out. No more waiting in line.
Thanks! Your answer is awaiting moderation.