Is $40.00 too much for two chefs salad and a small tip?

I would think so. But to my knowledge Millie's in Covina doesn't have a Chef's salad on their menu and usually their salads run roughly from $8 to $11 each.

The Salads start at $12.49 with The Chefs Salads and Steak Salads at $13.99 plus tax Unless you add xtra condiments and a tip. I believe yours came out to $34 to $35. and change with the tip. Millie’s