When I printed out my tickets they both have this same ticket number is that normal?

I think so. It is like an order number. As long as the seat numbers are different I think you are good to go.

You will have different seat numbers but the same order number. Print out your tickets, and its faster getting in.

Yes and then you have a seat #

Then you can pick the real ticket up at the theater or order it by mail.

I have printed out my tickets and the order number is on both but you should also have the seat numbers on it