Liberty Inn is a small town one night stop. Whenever you asked for another night, assuming you didn't do so at checkout time, the place may have been booked up at the time of your request. Surely Liberty Inn isn't judging the guests that stay there. As for your phone call, it's their business and you can report them to the BBB. No paying customer should be treated in that way.
Im not sure why they acted this way but they do like for you to check out if you only paid ahead for one night and not two.. Im not sure what thier policy is thought.. Im sorry you had a bad experience.. Hopefully if there is a next time it will be better..
Thanks! Your answer is awaiting moderation.