I pre-ordered a game and I live in New Rochelle. Is it possible for me to pick it up in a different location?

Technically you can't, but they made an exception for me when Sun & Moon were released. They'll refund your preorder and credit it as a gift card, you then use that amount on the card and pay the rest. And there you have it, that's how you pickup games at a GameStop where you didn't preorder a game originally. Of course they have to call it in with the store where you originally made the preorder.

No it has to be the sane game stop that you pre ordered it from @latoya

Call ahead first and see if they have it in stock if not you gonna have to go to the original game stop and get the game