Can you get there by public transportation from New York? Which the train New Jersey transit, Path train or Greyhound?

Public Transportation There is no direct service to the Land of Make Believe. BUS FROM PORT AUTHORITY NEW YORK CITY: Take Martz Trailways Bus to Stroudsburg Delaware Water Gap Bus Station, bus schedule available here. From there you will need to hire a taxi/limo service to take you to Hope, NJ. List of local taxi/limo companies available here. TRAIN FROM NEW YORK CITY AREA: Take a train to Hackettstown, NJ. NJTransit schedule. From there you will need to hire a taxi/limo service to take you to Hope, NJ. List of local taxi/limo companies available at Www.lomb.com

It is out on the middle of nowhere

I think so