Cousin Vinnies NY Pizza Cafe

Andrea Repetto

As it says on the door, "if you're in a hurry, you're in the wrong place!" But it's worth the wait!! Best Italian-American food I've had since I lived on the East Coast. Bread is fresh and savory. Bravo! * Don't miss the canolis! *

Mandy Green

You ring a doorbell to order and the guy and took our order. No dine in but he allowed me to sit inside since I was walking and 8.5 mths pregnant. He warned us the pizza would take awhile as he was there by himself working but wasn’t to bad of a wait considering. The pizza was okay. Probably a 6-7/10. Seems like a very hit or miss spot!

AB

So gross!!! We ordered three pizzas and they all looked and tasted like they had been reheated. We ended up just throwing it all away it was that bad. Considering our order cost $84 (no joke) I would have had better luck grabbing a frozen pizza from the grocery store for $8. Not sure how this guy is even still in business?? Total fraud!

Mitch Fisher

Getting a pizza here is the full authentic Brooklyn experience. The owner, the pictures in the restaurant, and most importantly the pizza all exceeded expectations. We ordered on the 4th of July right before close and the owner took good care of us.