Nicky's On the Bay

Category: Seafood restaurant in Bay Shore, New York

Address: 150 S Clinton Ave, Bay Shore, NY 11706, USA

Phone: +16312063311

Opening hours

Sunday: 11:30AM–10PM

Monday: 11:30AM–10PM

Tuesday: 11:30AM–10PM

Wednesday: 11:30AM–10PM

Thursday: 11:30AM–10PM

Friday: 11:30AM–10PM

Saturday: 11:30AM–10PM

Reviews

Jessica Ramdial

Jul 26, 2022

Fantastic food. From the first to the last bite it was absolutely delicious. I had the special which was the salmon w summer pasta. I loved it. The ambiance was very nice as well because your right on the water, very romantic if you go around sunset. Definitely can be a more casual dining experience. They have indoor and outdoor seating and a rooftop, that was not open when we were there. The only reason I'll be giving it 4 stars is because even tho the drinks were great, it took us quite a while to get a second. Service was a bit slow and we weren't checked on or taken care of as much as we should have. Other than that it was a very nice date night, but can also be a very family friendly place as well.

Denise Holzhauser

Jul 11, 2022

**A MUST TRY: their muscles in a blue cheese, garlic clove, and olive oil sauce. The blue cheese kicks the usual “garlic & oil” up a few notch’s! Yum 😋 The garlic cloves, not sliced or diced, melt in your mouth. And the sweetness, OMG…they must roast the garlic before adding the cloves into the sauce. Seriously guys, a must try! Five stars!

Tatiana Panova

Jul 11, 2022

Very nice place next to the water.I had to wait a bit on the waiting list.But the wait was worth it.The food was very tasty.A bit pricey though.But there is nothing wrong with that, If finances allow you and you want to have a good time.

Robert Papp

Aug 16, 2021

Went there with a party of 9. Nicole was the barmaid she was fantastic. Great personality and great drinks. Or waiter was not so good. We all got seafood and my daughter got a hamburger, her plate didn't come out for about 10 min after we all got out food. So by the time hers came out all our food was cold. They did take off the cost of the burger but unacceptable. The manager apologized and said they were very busy that day. Food was good nothing to get crazy about.

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.

Questions & Answers

Does Nicky's take reservations?

Maria DeLuca | May 12, 2020
MIA L | May 13, 2020

Yes

Read More

I came back and laura was my waiter she the best thank you 😊

Crist | Sep 14, 2020
Dan Manich | Sep 15, 2020

My experience there was excellent, view, food and service. Met Nicky and he is a very classy gentleman

Going to Nicky’s in June for 50th reunion is there any handicap enterence or way to get upstairs

A Google User | May 13, 2019
john boehm | May 14, 2019

I've only seen stairs to go upstairs.

Read More

Do they serve steak?

Nehemie Glezil | Aug 15, 2020
Ken Klapak | Aug 16, 2020

I don't recall seeing any steak on the menu.

Read More

When will Nicky's on the Bay be open for outdooor dining?

Andrew Elmore | Jun 16, 2020
Nicky's On the Bay (Owner) | Jun 17, 2020

Thursday June 12, 2020 full service dining on our outdoor seating area only Thank you hope to see you

Read More

Do they serve lobster tail or just whole lobster

GALE Heid | May 12, 2020
J .Gittleman | May 13, 2020

Both

Are dogs welcome here?

Chris I | May 12, 2020
Justin Allen | May 13, 2020

Service dogs

Read More

Can I make a reservation for July 4th. Thursday

Dino Gerbase | May 12, 2020
Justin Allen | May 13, 2020

You'd have to call ahead, I think they are booked.

Read More

Thanks! Your answer is awaiting moderation.

Thanks! Your question is awaiting moderation.

Related Places