GITANO Island

Category: Mexican restaurant in New York

Address: 125 Carder Rd, New York, NY 10004, USA

Opening hours

Sunday: 12–11PM

Monday: 12–10PM

Tuesday: 12–10PM

Wednesday: 12–10PM

Thursday: 12–11PM

Friday: 12–11PM

Saturday: 12–11PM

Reviews

Anacleto Bristol

Oct 13, 2022

I visited Gitano on a beautiful midsummer afternoon. As you can imagine, it was a very popular booking. We arrived right on time for our reservation but had to wait a while at the entrance. I figured out that the "Wait List" line was mixed with those who were waiting to be seated for confirmed bookings. I didn't understand why the two groups of people weren't separated. The situation would've been better served by two check-in staff members. We were finally seated and our initial waiter took our drink order. Strangely enough a second waitress came by to take our order again. The first waiter had apparently gone on break but I guess hadn't done a proper handoff (?) So we submitted our order again. Our food came out pretty quickly but then the drink bowl we ordered took forever and a day to follow. I thought that was strange becuase typically, drinks come out faster than the food. In any case, the drink bowl made sense for the amount. The food was great (the queso was so good and the guacamole was fresh). We finished our food and drink and took a stroll around the property. It really is a beautiful space. The DJ kept the groove going through a beautiful sunset (arguably the best time to go during the summer). They have so many different settings/enviroments to enjoy. These include formal dining tables, day beds, lounge seats etc. Whatever your event type is, I'm sure you can find the right space to perch. My only gripe in booking is that it's a little difficult trying to identify, visualize and book tables at the different spaces. My conclusions: It's worth a visit during the summer but for the price you're paying, the service and function need significant improvement.

SD dunu

Sep 27, 2022

Out of the world. Feel like you are in Jamaica with burning sage and hip music and lots of water features . Price is $$$ for food and drinks but worth the experience and time at this place

Jenniffer Medina

Sep 26, 2022

I expected more from this place, little variety of food, the food was not good. The service was not bad but they sat us in the place with the worst view when the restaurant was empty.

Irina Ryad

Sep 26, 2022

Disgusting customer service. No regard for repeating customers. Were falsely accused of cursing the host out after we were told to leave because he didn’t believe our dog is a service dog. Mind you, we were already let through by another hostess and were on our way to the bar area. Manager threatened to force us out by security and didn’t even bother to ask us what happened or hear our side of the story at all. It really seemed like a personal attack, a FALSE accusation and an awful response from very unprofessional staff and management. Used to really like it here but now the good memories are tainted by this awful, disgraceful and embarrassing experience. We actually celebrated our wedding anniversary here (along with our service dog)! We tried to bring my parents here today who happened to be in town. To think we thought this location is fit for important events in our and our families lives is now laughable. Will never spend another dime at this sham of a place because of their entitled posh and smug attitudes and we will make sure that we tell everyone we know what horrendous place this is. Never again.

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.

Questions & Answers

Do I need to be vaccinated, to dine in?

Mary Ann Shiell | Oct 8, 2022
Mary Stephens | Oct 8, 2022

No

Read More

Do you have vegan options on menu for night dinner?

Sushma K | Oct 8, 2022
Janice Hamilton | Oct 8, 2022

No. Haven’t seen any

Read More

What is the time for brunch

Kathryn Zakoscielny | Sep 8, 2022
Zzbeats101 clarke | Sep 8, 2022

I am not sure, I went in the evening and it was beautiful just from the ferry ride over

How do I change or cancel my reservation?

Leah McLaughlin | Aug 9, 2022
Jenn Vielman | Sep 8, 2022

By going to their website

Wich number can I call for make a reservation?

ALEX Lazarte | Aug 9, 2022
Hans Inglish | Aug 9, 2022

You have to make it on their website.

Can u drive directly to restaurant or do u have to take bridge or something from Manhattan?

Pina Odonnell | Aug 9, 2022
Bradlay Pryde | Aug 9, 2022

You have to take the Governor’s Island Ferry from Fidi in Manhattan.

What number can I call to make a reservation if the reservation website is not working and no one is responding to my emails to the restaurant ?

Victoria D M | Jul 10, 2022
Sergei Dudits | Aug 9, 2022

Just go there

Thanks! Your answer is awaiting moderation.

Thanks! Your question is awaiting moderation.

Related Places