Eileen's Special Cheesecake

Category: Bakery in New York

Address: 17 Cleveland Pl, New York, NY 10012, USA

Phone: +12129665585

Opening hours

Sunday: 11AM–7PM

Monday: 11AM–7PM

Tuesday: 11AM–7PM

Wednesday: 11AM–7PM

Thursday: 11AM–7PM

Friday: 11AM–8PM

Saturday: 11AM–8PM

Reviews

Hassan Saleh

Nov 7, 2022

Not impressed. The election of flavors is impressive but otherwise not much I can recommend. Tried three different flavors and all three had subpar filling, the taste, consistency, richness were all just not great. The crust I can’t really comment on as there was hardly any crust so the filling to crust ratio was awful. Would avoid it.

J Maguire

Nov 3, 2022

Truly authentic cheesecake shop found in little Italy, amazing flavours which cement the reasons why the shop gets all the accolades

Irene Kuo

Oct 31, 2022

They were not joking when they said this place had THE BEST cheesecakes. Over the last week I was hopping from dessert places to dessert places in hopes of finding the best cheesecake. Right now, Eileen’s has the crown and nothing has come close yet. I got the: Plain cheesecake ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Salted Caramel ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ (pretty great but compared to the plain one, nah)

Miguel Trejo

Oct 31, 2022

A lot of different flavors! I order Strawberry, caramel, cookies and cream and raspberry and all was really good!

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.

Questions & Answers

Do they do just by the slice or only whole cheesecakes?

Aysha (TankGirL) | Nov 8, 2018
*C. ** | Nov 8, 2018

They have mini and larger Cheesecakes

Read More

Can the cheesecake be frozen?

Tamara Hocking | Nov 8, 2018
Akash Goswami | Nov 8, 2018

Yes it can be

Read More

Do I need to order in advanced for 6" cheesecakes? I am thinking of getting the special on the menu.

George Zhang | Nov 8, 2019
Carlos Osorio Sordelli | Nov 8, 2019

Order in advance. Best in the country

Read More

Do they have Japanese cheese cake?

Sara HSS | Nov 8, 2018
Bert Welch | Nov 8, 2018

No! Its American Cheesecake. Never heard of Japanese Cheesecake. ELW

Read More

Do your cheesecakes have a pastry crust?

Eileen Fulton | Nov 8, 2018
Gregor L | Nov 8, 2018

My recollection is most were gramcracker crust.

Read More

Are you guys kosher.

Peter Pinkhasov | May 11, 2022
nedynia lopez | May 11, 2022

I don't know, I tried the cherry cheesecake it was excellent

Do they have vegan cheesecake?

Lindsay Best | May 11, 2022
Tom Tytunovich | May 11, 2022

They do not.

Do they have Iced Americano?

April | Nov 7, 2021
Helmy Ruiz | Nov 7, 2021

Yes

Read More

What are the Covid safety practices like here?

Anonymous | Nov 7, 2022
Clifford Lee | Nov 7, 2021

it is a small place so only 1 to 2 customer at a time if you picking up an online or ordering. masks required to enter. line wraps around the corner to Kenmare Street. from what I saw every employee was also masked and gloves.

does this place do red velvet chesse cakes?

Mz Amethiyst/Aquarius Graham | Nov 7, 2021
Khushi Doshi | Nov 7, 2021

Yes, I saw red velvet when I was there

Can they make a mocha cheesecake?

Kyle Kulka | Nov 7, 2021
wilson grafals | Nov 7, 2021

Dont know, call em

Read More

Do you have raspberry cheesecakes?

Betzy P | Nov 7, 2020
SONIDEROS | Nov 7, 2020

Yes if they dont, do not worry you will fall in love with anything else.

Is cash only or they take credit cards?

Apple Ho | Nov 8, 2019
Erdem Kent | Nov 8, 2019

They take cards

How much is the large cheesecake?

Sultana Razia | Nov 8, 2019
Ming Hai Lim | Nov 8, 2019

12 inch is ISD98, large sheet is USD295

Read More

Hi! Do you have any gluten free option?

Florencia Muriel Gonzalez | Nov 8, 2019
Timothy Carey | Nov 8, 2019

On special request yes. They currently do not advertise on there menu.

Read More

Is this open Christmas day?

K M | Nov 8, 2019
ANNEGRET Voelker | Nov 8, 2019

I can't answer the question because I don't know the opening times. Google certainly knows.

How much is one slide of cheese cake?

Sinai Cisneros | Nov 8, 2019
Gaia Malavasi | Nov 8, 2019

It's about 4.50$ .. I could give even 10 dollars for it 😍

I want the adress

Eilana Tzubary | Nov 8, 2018
Ahmad Khan | Nov 8, 2018

17 Cleveland place, New York, NY 10012.

Do you ship to other states.

willie morales | Nov 8, 2017
Nizel Adams | Nov 8, 2017

Yes they ship to all states

Do you deliver to the times square area?

Tanya de la Vergne | Nov 8, 2017
Nizel Adams | Nov 8, 2017

They can deliver anywhere in the U.S. with next day shipping

Read More

Thanks! Your answer is awaiting moderation.

Thanks! Your question is awaiting moderation.

Related Places