AJ's OldTown Steakhouse & Tavern

lisamichelle

Finally got to try this place out & was not impressed. Steak was way undercooked, ordered a medium well, got a very rare & bloody steak. Steak was placed on top of potatoes so my potatoes ended up being bloody as well.

Ronald Kibort

A great steak 🥩.

Nicole

This was my 1st time here as this is my 1st time in Homer. AJ's had great reviews so I decided to try it for dinner and it did not disappoint. I ended up getting the Pan seared Halibut with truffle fries. Both were delicious. The only thing I would recommend is if you're going on a Saturday night is to try to make reservations. I was able to get a spot at the bar, but the rest of it looked reserved also.

Shelly Bishop

Went in for the first and last time. The hostess was rude as hell. The waitress was not too much better. The girl busing tables was the nicest person there. I ordered the fish and chips. Literally hands down the worst fish and chips I've had around here. They charged $32 for fish that dry and tasted like over cooked fish patties out the freezer. I literally did not even finish one piece of fish. My husband's burger was okay at best. Fries were over cooked. The cheese curds were the best thing we ate. Good thing we ate them all. Worse $80 I've ever wasted.