Old Mill Creamery

Tina Rimner

We have been going to the Creamery for over 31 years. This is the 1st place we go when our family gets settled into our vacation stay. I always order a banana split. Not this year, the past 2 years have been very disappointing. The service is not the same and the banana split is horrible. I wished I could post the pictures of the banana split from the past and the present very disappointing. They last2 visits they have not even had Bananas. We will be finding another ice cream place to go from now own

Anna and Kevin

Unfortunately, didn't have flavors advertised on their website, but still good & don't seem to have the same aversion to dogs on their patio that the nearby grill does.

jason hyer

Really good ice cream and prices!

gary tilson

Asked for 2 scoops of Nutter Butter ice cream. Lady showed 1 scoop and asked if I was sure I wanted 2. Most places this was 2 scoops. Daughter had black cherry. Both were incredibly rich and probably the most reasonably priced thing in PF.