Gennaro's Italian Market & Catering

Tom Z

We were excited to dine here and it was not what we expected based on the reviews we read here. Started off with a bread roll each, no butter and looked almost like it was made with pizza dough (a good thing). They did have a cruet of oil that had pepper corns on the table so I figured that was for the bread, nothing to be excited about. The coconut shrimp did not have any almonds (not a bad thing, but it wasn’t as advertised unless they were powdered 🤷‍♂️). The zucchini croquettes lacked salt but were otherwise very good. The veal Marsala (not on the menu but they indicated on the menu they make other dishes) was good, but wasn’t spectacular. Tried the Pappardelle di Manzo, sorry I did, pretty pedestrian. I was able to discern one, yes one, mushroom in the dish and didn’t taste any ricotta. The dish lacked any real flavor to make it stand out, a total disappointment even though it indicated it was fresh pasta. They refilled our water glasses without any ice so we had to drink room temperature water, what’s up with that? For 2 people to have coconut shrimp, zucchini croquettes, veal Marsala and the parpadelle came to a $95 bill…..sorry, but to me, that was exorbitant amount of $ for pretty pedestrian food. With that being said, we will definitely not be back….they are lucky I rated it at 3 stars, my wife wanted 2 stars…I feel bad as I haven’t written a bad review in years, yet here it is…this establishment earned it.

user user

Toooooo expensiveeeeee

C Rota

Excellent excellent excellent food true Italian cuisine for the takeout at the deli's tremendous when I found them I was ecstatic stop by whenever I'm in the area can get a chance tremendous food hopefully when this stupid sickness thing is over with I can get back there on a regular basis definitely got to check them out thank you. Made it back yesterday! Great!

Alexi Assmus, PhD

Excellent. Hidden gem. Wonderful meals in a casual setting, with the quality of food that of a fine dining restaurant, and terrific selections at the Italian grocery alongside, which has their wonderful ravioli, homemade gelato, and much more.