Address: 3455 Grove City Rd, Grove City, OH 43123, USA
Phone: +16149910352
Sunday: 12–5PM
Monday: 12–6PM
Tuesday: 12–6PM
Wednesday: 12–6PM
Thursday: 12–6PM
Friday: 12–6PM
Saturday: 12–5PM
E C
Brought some Pokemon cards in awhile back. Got Kindof dismissed, eventually a guy behind the counter told me he could take a look and offered me $400. For 3000 original base set cards. Maybe he didn't know what he was looking at, but I sold them for $3000 on eBay a week later.
Andy Tallman
Visited while on a road trip driving through town. Nate who was working that day was amazing. Super knowledgeable, friendly and took his time with me as I debated between a bunch of products! Ended up with a few products to take home to open with a friend. Great shop with fair prices that was well worth the stop on our trip!
GC PokéPlayer
Way over priced
Jaime Sotelo
Coming from California I didn't know what to expect. This place had it all. The amount of variety was amazing. From singles, packs, boxes, and graded cards. All sports as well. The staff was very helpful. A great group wanting to help. They are also great with kids getting into collecting.
Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.
I have a whole collection in a binder from when I was a kid that I’m looking to sell, I don’t know the value of it at all and if you guys buy I left a voicemail and my number to give me a call back
Yes 👍
I have to say that I agree. They are exceptionally fair when it comes to pricing. They're rather limited on what they're buying currently but blame the government and the politicians for that...but if you've got a numbered card or an autographed numbered card and want a secure and safe flip stop in....I had a few nice sets I was pushing to get rid of that under normal financial circumstances they'd have snatched up but they passed and I unfairly, after my second visit, misjudged them. I pulled a PANINI Donruss '22 UFC Charles Oliveira autographed purple lazer and from all I saw it was going for about $100-$120 high end. I do plenty of buying and reselling with housewares and predominantly vintage toys so I'm well aware of the one-third mentality. In fact I expect it. The gentlemen was NOT the owner though I have met the owner several times but he asked what I was looking to get? I said $30...$35 if I'm lucky. He looks it up and immediately says they're selling for $80 and in my mind
PART 2 I ran out of room on your other question brother...I don't know if you meant to write a review or what but it was in it questions section and so I was replying.... So when he says $80 I immediately think he's gonna low ball me. I quickly responded that on ebay there were not a one for $80 but before I could spit it out he says he can offer me $50!!! I was shocked honestly. And I apologize for misjudging the business before. I understand why you're only buying rare stuff and I appreciate the courtesy and respect you gave me when doing business with you. I don't deal in cards often but when I do it'll be with these great guys at this very nice local business! Thanks again guys!!
Do they have booster packs or it individual rare Card's?
Last i talked to an expert, it jumped from 80 all the way up to damn near 300- something, but to make matters worse p.s.a. is backed up by years with cards waiting to be graded. It's crazy
Anthony - not really. We don't do a whole lot of hockey, especially vintage hockey. We may have a card or two but I doubt there's much. We're always trying to expand our offerings so I will keep an eye out for more vintage hockey in the future. Thanks!
Amazing place and the staff is great too! Love collecting cards come here!
Not typically. Mostly looking for 50-60's super stars like Mantle, Mays, etc. as well as newer cards (jerseys, autographs, etc.) from the last 5 years or so (preferably of bigger names). We are happy to take a look though if you're looking to get an idea of what you have and what it may be worth. Just don't want to make any promises on buying anything we may or may not be able to use in our store.
Yes he buys cards
Thanks! Your answer is awaiting moderation.
Thanks! Your question is awaiting moderation.