Setauket Pastaria

M Towner

I've been to Setauket Pasteria many times for take-out and dine-in and never been disappointed.

jason wachter

Food never came…Ordered food an hour before closing, they were nice, said it would be about 20min. 10min after calling they called us back, asking if we wanted to add the tip on the card. Reassuring everything is going well. Time goes by, getting closer and closer to closing. We didbt want to be overly eager as 20min, 30min 40min has come and gone. Now it’s 5min before closing so we call and no one picks up. We call and call and no one picks up. Some type of messed up practical joke played out at our expense.

Laura Paterson

Went with my daughter and granddaughter today. Food was delicious and young man behind the counter was very helpful. Best customer service we have experienced

Maureen

Best Grandma pie on Long Island!