Scavello's On The Island

Mariska Dudley

My family and I came out for lunch. We saw on google that the restaurant opens at 1pm but when we got there the restaurant was closed. We found out that the restaurant actually opens at 3pm. The restaurant owner paul, was beyond phenomenal, he decided to accommodate us at the restaurant despite they won’t opened as yet. Service was impeccable, food was delicious and fresh. My family and I enjoyed everything. Paul was so pleasant, kind and patient. This by far has been one of my best restaurant experiences in a very long time. I highly recommend and I will definitely come back again!!! Give them a ten star rating.

Brian

Fantastic place for either a step-above sit down meal or a quick grab-and-go (thanks to the lower level deli-style quick mart). Food is consistently yummy, with expected City Island prices. I utilize the quick mart weekly for par-cooked oven full dishes or daily essentials. Affordable wine and beer available. Kind and courteous employees round out the experience for a 5-star location. Love it! (Download the rewards app!!!)

R Niles

I was invited to a wedding here. The place was very beautiful. The staff were pleasant. I enjoyed my food. Would recommend it.

Fellon

Food was great, cozy, intimate setting. Servers and bartender was excellent!