Replay Sports

sherrie corvera

Unfortunately did not have a good experience here, partially my own fault. Came for a baseball mitt, which I did not research the prices for in the store before I bought it, but it turned out to be less expensive brand new. It was in great condition, but could have spent $25 less for brand new. The staff didn’t even acknowledge that we were in the store and I have to agree with another reviewer that the woman behind the counter couldn’t be bothered with even looking at us as we were checking out. I’ll be heading to another sports consignment store (that I usually use but wanted to give this place a try) in the future. Much more friendly and helpful staff there.

michelle minich

Called ahead to see if they have a size 11 left hand throw baseball glove. Woman who answered the phone says “Yes, we have many, you’ll have to come look.” They have gloves, even have 4 for left hand throwers, but no size 11. It’s no sweat off their back that I just drove an hour round trip because she couldn’t be bothered to walk 40’ to the back of the store and spend 2 minutes checking inventory. Also, the prices on these used gloves are high. Not returning in the future.

Jay Marcus

It's best for hockey equipment. If you need hockey stuff, this is the place to go. There's some baseball, but we didn't find what we were looking for.

CC AA

Lots of ice hockey gear for good prices and very helpful staff!