Monticello Bagel Bakery

Category: Bakery in Monticello, New York

Address: 475 Broadway, Monticello, NY 12701, USA

Phone: +18457947746

Opening hours

Sunday: 5AM–3PM

Monday: 4:30AM–3PM

Tuesday: 4:30AM–3PM

Wednesday: 4:30AM–3PM

Thursday: 4:30AM–3PM

Friday: 4:30AM–3PM

Saturday: 5AM–3PM

Reviews

Kyle L

Oct 13, 2022

Best Bagels Hands Down. Made fresh daily. A must try if your in the area. You won't be disappointed.

Faith Miskell

Oct 9, 2022

Was looking forward to trying their bagels while I was in town. Finally got our food, my bf got a monster sandwich, the meat was undercooked otherwise good. My first bagel was okay. I wanted an everything bagel so I went back, used the drive thru. Ordered an everything bagel toasted with butter and cc . The bagel was very dry no butter, the cream cheese was hard and globbed on, it was sloppy and had cream cheese on the package that got all over my pants. Very disappointed with my experience. Overall, the effort put into our food was poor the bagel it's self was delicious but lacked butter and cream cheese that was soft the meat and hash brown were under cooked and the bagel was dry and poorly made.

K silly Di

Oct 6, 2022

Bagels were fresh and delicious.

Krista Sabatino

Sep 27, 2022

The workers are doing a great job. Management should stop yelling at them. (Not Brian. The other one)

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.

Questions & Answers

Do they really open At 4 a.m.

Kyle Munigle | Oct 18, 2019
MarkAnthony Rodriguez | Oct 18, 2019

Absolutely, full service too. We have been there plenty of times for fresh bagels and breakfast sandwiches!

Read More

Do they take foodstamps?

Margaret Green | Aug 18, 2022
Amanda Magee | Aug 18, 2022

No, they don't.

Do you deliver?

ELIZABETH GROMADSKI | Aug 18, 2022
Monticello Bagel Bakery | Aug 18, 2022

We deliver to local businesses but not to private residences.

Are you now shipping out begals

Maryann Indrunas | Mar 21, 2022
Monticello Bagel Bakery | Mar 21, 2022

I’m sorry we are not

Do they send bagels out of state

Ann Welber | Oct 17, 2021
Josh Williams | Oct 17, 2021

They do have a store section on their website that mentions they ship across the country, but you may have to get in touch by phone to place the order.

What time do they stop the grill

Michael Padilla | Oct 18, 2019
mari bella | Oct 18, 2019

I know they're closed by 4pm

Quite literally the best bagels on planet Earth. I don't know what they do different, but it's worked just deliciously for the 20+ years I've been eating these.

William LoCascio | Oct 18, 2019
Hershy Weisberger | Oct 18, 2019

She asked the Almighty

Thanks! Your answer is awaiting moderation.

Thanks! Your question is awaiting moderation.

Related Places