Pioneer Pizza

Tamara Prezioso

I am visiting Plain City, my hometown, after moving out of state 16 years ago and was hopeful because I have loved all the pizza from Plain City in the past, and I even worked at one in the 90’s. This pizza disappointed me in both taste and texture as the crust is too thick and the overall taste too salty.

eric harden

So glad we gave this another try tonight. Small cauliflower crust, 3 topping and a small original crust all the way. Honestly, hard to tell the difference in the crust. Cauliflower was a bit thinner and crispier. Both were executed perfectly! The sauce was a bit sweeter than I usually like but, it worked. Ordered through ToastTab for take out and it was ready ahead of time and piping hot. Great job!

Tim Sturgill

Really wish I could give a review on the pizza, but I sure have one on the service. Arrived at 550 on a Friday Night. We ordered one large one topping pizza. Gave them the table number as requested by the bartender that took our order. We had a soccer match for our son that would be starting at 730 so we thought we would be good on time. Absolutely not the case. By 645 no pizza, so I drive my son to his game and the wife stays back to wait for the pizza. By 705 still no pizza. We gotta go, so the wife asks some random waitress what's going on. She says...oh we gave your pizza to someone else we can have something out in 5 minutes. 10 minutes later I asked for a refund. We'll see if it goes through. I hate giving poor reviews but thus one is deserving in every way.

Julie Hi

The Cauliflower pizza with homemade sausage is the best!