Johnny Brusco's New York Style Pizza

Eden Stancill

I’d like to first say we’ve eaten here a bunch of times and the pizza is great, but tonight I had a very bizarre and bad experience with the staff that I feel compelled to share. I placed a to-go order at about 7:15pm for two pizzas. Girl on the phone was friendly and said give them about 25 minutes. I show up at 7:40 and there’s a sign on the door that says “store closes at 8:30.” I go to open the door and it’s locked. I knocked on the door, called repeatedly, could see employees inside buzzing around but nobody would answer the phone or the door. After standing there for about ten minutes, a young couple came up to walk in and I told them the door is locked and nobody will open it or answer the phone. The guy said “a buddy of mine works here, let me call him.” A few seconds later a young employee comes and opens the door and I said “your door is locked” and he said “yeah sorry.” I walk in and there are two women sitting there waiting for their order and they said “they had the door locked and we had to beat on it too - we’re just trying to get our to go order.” When I walked up to the counter a female employee looked at the guy who opened the door and held her hands up like “why did you do that?” To which I said “I placed a to go order…can I have it or not?” She whipped her head around and walked away. The young guy who unlocked the door checked me out and I left. I fully understand that employees don’t want to stay past closing time, but it was almost an hour prior to closing AND they accepted my to-go order but didn’t want to let me in to get it. Extremely bizarre. Would love to know if the owner of this place knows how the staff is running things.

Matthew Nellis

Cheese breadsticks were good, bbq wings were great, but the pizza was disappointing., but I just moved here from NY and I knew it wasn't gonna be easy finding great pizza here.

Kevin Houston

I ordered a pizza with grilled chicken and tomatoes, light cheese and sauce which is all options on there web site. I got pizza with tomatoes on one side and chicken on the other which I ordered online So I go to pick up and I'm guessing the manager who's sitting at the end of the bar drinking beer doesn't know what a online order looks like, actually questioned whether it was a online or call in order, what a joke, definitely wouldn't recommend

Matt Trager

Delicious authentic slices. Great service