Benkert's Bakery

Category: Bakery

Address: 2216 Middle Country Rd, Centereach, NY 11720, USA

Phone: +16315858618

Opening hours

Sunday: 6AM–6PM

Monday: 7AM–6PM

Tuesday: 7AM–6PM

Wednesday: 7AM–6PM

Thursday: 7AM–6PM

Friday: 7AM–6PM

Saturday: 6AM–6PM

Reviews

Elaine Supinski

Oct 6, 2022

They have been in business for over 50 years and make the best rye bread ever.

D-Rob Travel Co

Sep 15, 2022

A wonderful family run bakery with so many incredible pastries and breads that I've never seen some of them anywhere else! Certainly worth the stop! Very competitive prices in general too. Great place for a cake or cupcakes!

Rachel Liebert

Sep 15, 2022

Benkert's assembled a creative wedding cake that blew my guests away! We sampled quite a few carrot cakes on Long Island and Benkert's far outshone all of the others. We loved that they were able to do carrot cake and a raspberry lemon layer so that all of our guests had something to enjoy. We will definitely be coming back for our anniversary!

Samantha Curran

Aug 30, 2022

Delicious strawberry cheesecake. Love the cannolis and brownies!! All the workers are so nice and helpful with picking out the perfect pastries and cake. Cant wait to go back for more!

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.

Questions & Answers

What are the Covid safety practices like here?

Anonymous | Oct 13, 2022
Andrew Lorch | Oct 13, 2021

On holidays we also have someone working the door to limit amount of people inside and help enforce social distancing, we also will have for the holiday week a tent to help keep customers out of the elements

Read More

Do you have German Bee cake?

Lydia Koch | Oct 13, 2020
Nancy Cullon | Oct 13, 2020

I have no clue lol. Evetything is yummy there. Call them they are located in centereach. I believe their hours are till 6pm earlier than what web says.

Why did the previous owners sell so quickly and secretly?

Meg Malangone | Oct 13, 2020
Benkert's Bakery | Oct 13, 2020

There was no sale of the Bakery, it has been the same owners for over 25 years. We did a remodel but for whatever reason people thinks that goes along with a sale, but it did not.

Read More

Do they sell prosciutto bread?

Fayjai Mike | Oct 13, 2020
pushpa latha | Oct 13, 2020

Its better to call them Fayjai

Read More

DO YOU MAKE DARK PUMPERNICKEL BREAD WITH RASINS

DONALD ROMANO | Oct 13, 2020
Benkert's Bakery | Oct 13, 2020

Yes we make it both with and without rasins

Read More

Were you originally called Pies Plus?

Jay Ambers | Oct 14, 2019
Madison | Oct 14, 2019

I don't think it was ever called that

Do you send cookies ??

Barbara Mccauley | Oct 14, 2019
Rich Zbik | Oct 14, 2019

Don't know but there good

Anything Gluten Free?

Matt | Oct 14, 2018
john sitone | Oct 14, 2018

Yes

I want to order a 1/4 sheet of 1/2 apple and i/2 cherry crumb cake.Do I have to come in to do that?

Sal Greco | Oct 14, 2018
Mike Cousins | Oct 14, 2018

She's right, just call them. Do yourself a favor, try the Brooklyn cheesecake when you go there, delicious.

Read More

Is the fondant bitter or sweet

akari lopez | Oct 14, 2017
Timothy M. Gaffney | Oct 14, 2017

Sweet

Do you have brithday mikey mouse cake

Bruce Zieman | Oct 14, 2017
Charlie Yurick | Oct 14, 2017

Yes

Read More

Thanks! Your answer is awaiting moderation.

Thanks! Your question is awaiting moderation.

Related Places