I Love NY Pizza

Sean Waterford

Everyone raves about this place and don’t get me wrong, it’s decent food- but when you pay significantly more than a chain pizza place and the food is just okay(the sauce really lacks flavor)it’s disappointing. We wanted to love this place, but between the very abrupt and almost rude customer service, expensive pricing (6.50 for one cannoli!!) and only okay taste, it’s not worth the time and effort to patronize this establishment. I could name a couple other North Atlanta places that are much better. So disappointed. I really don’t know what the other reviewers were basing their reviews on, but we’ve eaten pizza globally and had high hopes..Oh well.

Jonathan Gallagher

Excellent pizza. Do your self a favor if your in the area and.get some pizza. Super friendly staff.

Jennifer Waits

Went today and the worker was playing on his phone never washed his hands then touched my pizza with no gloves. Then went to make a salad which also didn’t wash his hands or put on gloves. Very friendly but I would feel much better if there were gloves or some hand washing going on.

Bülent Güneş

Some of the best pizza I’ve ever had! All of the ingredients were fresh and the pizza looked like a symmetrical piece of food art. We had the Pizza and added pepperoni. You could tell the pizza maker took his time placing every ingredient evenly across the pizza so that every bite was amazingly balanced. Also, had a large Garden Salad and it was delicious and fresh. Always good to balance out the unhealthy with some healthy LOL. When I called the restaurant to make my order the staff members were polite and very hospitable. Glad we’ve found this local treasure for our future pizza orders! Great job