Cosmic Pizza

Greg Crotser

I'm from NY and this is pretty darn good, best I've had in a while Edit: upon returning I ordered a large rather than doing individual slices and it was completely different pizza. At my first visit, the pizza was light, crisp, and flavorful. But when I ordered the whole pizza, it was chewy to the point my jaw was fatiguing and rather bland to the point where I was just throwing the crusts out which in my mind is the mark of a poor pie. I'll have to return a third time to determine which visit is most representative of their typical quality, but my recommendation for now would be to only do individual slices.

E

2 slices and a drink for $7 you can’t beat it. And soooo tasty too.

Michael Poplin

This is really good pizza if you're into the greasy slice. Interesting combos, quality ingredients and so far they aren't stingy (which is good because it's pretty expensive.) I think best in Bozeman but pretty low bar, surprisingly? Anywho, 3 stars because they're kind of flaky but it's staffed by college-age folks that are pretty familiar with herbs no doubt. This could be okay and even charming, except that last time we ordered over the phone with a credit card, we showed up to pick up and the credit card was written on a piece of paper and we're not sure if it was ever disposed of in a correct manner. Sure, you could shred it but it's 2022 and this is a terrible practice. Their POS merchant would have a panic attack if they knew about this sort of thing. Will gladly re-adjust this rating but hoping to get management's attention because that's a laughably terrible security practice.

Allie Kresen

honestly so good. I'm from the east coast originally and had a hard time finding great, casual pizza (lots of brick oven in the area which is all good but...you know what I mean) since moving here, but this is classic ny style, floppy but not too floppy, generous toppings, it's got it all. & that cosmic sauce 🤌