Huntley Taverne

John DuVal

We really enjoy this place but had quite a surprising and unfortunate experience this weekend. Our family had dinner here last night for a special occasion. Unfortunately, our waitress spilled red wine on us when she was serving our first round of drinks. My wife's sweater, my mother's blouse, and my father's shirt were all stained pretty well. They moved us to a new section with a new waiter. The meal was lovely, and we really enjoyed the food and atmosphere. The manager apologized for the spill. However, for dessert they gave me 1 less scoop of sorbet than my wife received, and we were charged the same full price for both dishes 🤔 The most surprising thing though, was that nothing was taken off the bill for the inconvenience of having 3/4 of guests' clothes damaged at the beginning of our dinner. I am not one to ask for things to be comped, but still, this felt odd to me. For a restaurant of this caliber, I have to say I was a bit surprised that we weren't compensated in some way for this. I understand everyone makes mistakes and we did not make a fuss and it didn't ruin our night. It's just a bit surprising, and I felt uneasy debating the bill at the end of the night in front of my family and in a busy restaurant. Hopefully we'll be back. But honestly not sure when.

Angela Luisa

Thanks to a quick Google search we found this delicious restuarant near the Short Hills Mall and I’m soooo glad we did. Me and my Fiancé are huge foodies so we love to eat out and have nice experiences on Friday nights. This actually exceeded our expectations. Even the way this restuarant answers the phone makes you want to come and dine with them. What made it even better was our waitress, Sydney. She was by far the friendliest waitress we’ve ever had before. She had great recommendations and made sure we had everything we needed at all times. Not to mention, every single thing we ate blew us away. I cannot recommend this restaurant enough! We will certainly be back, it’s worth the drive!

Katherine L Anderson

Always love the Huntley Tavern! Their signature cocktails are never a disappointment.

P R

Food is pretty good so is the atmosphere. It get pretty packed on Friday nights and the server was clearly rushing us out after we paid.