Lisa's Pie Shop

Category: Pie shop

Address: 5995 US-31, Atlanta, IN 46031, USA

Phone: +13177586944

Opening hours

Sunday: Closed

Monday: Closed

Tuesday: 10AM–6PM

Wednesday: 8AM–6PM

Thursday: 8AM–6PM

Friday: 8AM–6PM

Saturday: 10AM–5PM

Reviews

Darren Bowman

Jun 11, 2022

The pies are amazing, well worth the money and the drive. The shop smells awesome when you walk in. It was great to see cars lining up in the lot before she had even opened. Would recommend Lisa's to anyone.

Holly Faust

Oct 31, 2021

Lady who waited on us very nice. They don't take cards, only cash or check. Was asked to wear a mask due to the owner is fighting cancer, so immunocompromised. I have no problem wearing a mask. Bought blueberry pie, delish!!

Leila Harris

Jul 29, 2021

Great pies, and quiche. Wearing a mask helps people with compromised immune systems, so its shouldn't be an issue for a few minutes of anyone's time, especially if your helping others to keep healthy. I'm grateful that this place is still going strong, because my family loves her baking!

Ashley Segal

Feb 27, 2021

Great places. I would personally make some different changes to the Dutch apple pie by making the filling a little bit more sweeter and do not like the icing on the cinnamon rolls. The cinnamon roll itself is real good. Other than that, so so so good on the selection and taste. I still eat the Dutch apple pie. I am def eager to try the other pies, bread and cookies.

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.

Questions & Answers

What is the phone number?

Veronica Maxwell | May 4, 2019
Barbara Smith | May 5, 2019

(317) 758- 6944 Hours of Operation: Closed Sunday & Monday. Tuesday 10:00 am-6:00 pm. Wednesday - Friday 8:00 am- 6:00 pm. Saturday 10:00 am- 5:00 pm

Do you take debit cards!

Melody Chenoweth | May 4, 2019
Erin O'Riordan | May 5, 2019

No, they are a cash-only business.

Read More

Do you make raisin pie and how much?

Bruce Montgomery | May 4, 2019
Barbara Smith | May 5, 2019

Raisin Pie is considered Specialty pie. Specialty pies are $15 each. Basic pies are $12 each.

Thanks! Your answer is awaiting moderation.

Thanks! Your question is awaiting moderation.

Related Places