Pietro's Brick Oven Pizzeria

Life of Agony N.Y.H.C

Best pasta in my opionion on Long Island. So sad to hear of the passing of the owner. He was so nice and always said hi when I picked up my food. Rest in piece my friend

Bari Bakhtari

UPDATE: This is terrible. I just got the news that Pietro actually passed away. He was always such a generous and kind guy. My condolences go out to his family. I don't know where to begin; the desserts, the pizza, the stuffed chicken Parmesan - it's all so delicious. Pietro and his team do their very best in an effort to deliver quality and professionalism - never once have they failed in bringing exactly that. They're all so hard-working and are always (extreme understatement) generous as far as portions go. Thank you Pietro, thank you to your team, and thank you for such amazing service.

Earl w Borden

Amazing pizza but whoever anws answered the phone to take my order had no idea what they were doing and screwed my order up and gave me buffalo calamari instead of just regular which really ruined my night can't eat spicy stuff

Chris M

I moved from Northport to Oyster Bay and was worried I wouldn't be able to find a pizzeria as good as La Casa, but Pietro's definitely impressed me. The food is great, the ingredients are fresh, and everyone seems friendly and happy to be there. I was also surprised to see upside down pizza (sauce as a top layer) on the menu, I haven't seen that since growing up in Queens in the 80's. Highly recommended, I'm glad they're in the neighborhood.