New York Pizzeria

Meanest Mom Of the West

Service was decent considering the amount of customers. I didn't love the pizza. Crust was crispy but I like my toppings to over power it so I don't taste the bread. That's just my opinion though.

Matt Terzi

Our family has made it a habit, a tradition really, to visit the Fly Creek Cider Mill at least two or three times each year. We normally get pizza in Oneonta, but this trip we decided to try something a little different and try New York Pizzeria in Cooperstown. And now, this place is joining our Fly Creek tradition. Our whole family loved the pizza, the staff was super friendly, it's just a short drive from Fly Creek, and the interior is clean and aesthetically pleasing. Great food, atmosphere, and staff? Yeah. We'll be back again for sure.

A. LeDuc

Delicious pizza and mozzarella sticks. Sticky tables and high chairs,, but yummo I haven't had pizza this good in I can't remember when. 5 stars if things were a bit cleaner. I don't want to have to wipe the high chairs before we sit.

Mamadou Diallo

Born and bred New Yorker and I gotta say there slices was way better than expected. Lunch special at $5 for 2 slices and a drink had me feeling like I was back in the city, kind dudes, satisfying experience, can’t go wrong!