The Lobster Roll Amagansett

Parker Davis

Loved it. Arrived at 2:30 on Saturday for a 15-minute wait. Service was as-expected for the scene. There’s a bar window for anyone waiting to be seated—no hassle to find a gap at the bar. The food was solid for the scene. Ideal for groups of 2-6.

Rebekah S

The lobster roll Amagansett is a staple in town. It’s very family friendly with a large selection of lobster rolls, fried fish, soups, salads, and fried food. There’s also a big drink menu too. Staff are very friendly too!

André Nicolas

We tried this restaurant on our way to Montauk and believe me it is a MUST to stop for a lobster bisque. The service is great, the ambience is also amazing: it is always packed with people and staff. We took our baby with a stroller and there was room enough around the table. Loved the lobster roll, it has plenty of meat. We tried the nachos...not so good and the key lime pie, you must try them. The key lime pie has been on their menu for many years and they claim to be the best!

Santhosh G

Visited this place in summer as a tourist attraction after watching The Affair tv show. Still preserving the same setup inside and outside giving the great feel of living in the show and actors. Tried their famous lobster roll and it’s delicious. Also tried the salad with veggie patty and it’s super rich with pistachios, cranberries and lot of veggies. Higher on the price range and there is long wait in the peak season but worth the wait.