New York Pizza Fleming Island

Category: Pizza restaurant in Fleming Island, Florida

Address: 1811 Golden Eagle Way #25, Fleming Island, FL 32003, USA

Phone: +19045793488

Opening hours

Sunday: 12–9PM

Monday: 10:30AM–9PM

Tuesday: 10:30AM–9PM

Wednesday: 10:30AM–9PM

Thursday: 10:30AM–9PM

Friday: 10:30AM–10PM

Saturday: 10:30AM–10PM

Reviews

ProZay

Oct 6, 2022

yummy pizza

Jacob Gillean

Sep 21, 2022

Meh. Not bad but not outstanding either.

Josh

Aug 31, 2022

Just ordered two pizzas today one cheese and one pepperoni. There is no other way to describe the pepperoni pizza than disgusting I’m a usual customer so I’m normally satisfied but today my pepperoni pizza was oily and the crust was so thin it was transparent not to mention the taste was horrible. The bottom of the box was coated in grease unfortunately I won’t be ordering here again

Ms. Daisy

Aug 21, 2022

It says NY Pizza. It's close enough. I enjoyed my pizza, and the wings were delicious—excellent size and meaty. I had the garlic and sweet chili wings. I could not choose which one was my favorite.

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.

Questions & Answers

So since the Ava’s has been closed you still haven’t changed the signs

CreaksOFFICAL | Oct 7, 2018
Vickie Neilen | Oct 7, 2018

Logos are in the windows Go In and give it a try!

What are the Covid safety practices like here?

Anonymous | Oct 6, 2022
frank letchese | Oct 6, 2021

No masks

Do you deliver?

Sandie Domando | Oct 7, 2017
Yenier Ramirez | Oct 7, 2017

Yup

Waited 1:53 past delivery time. Why quote a time if you’re not holding up to delivery time. Paid and placed tip, big mistake because they are always late. Not the first time. Bad for business because your lying

Kim Mcgough | Oct 6, 2021
New York Pizza Fleming Island | Oct 6, 2021

I’m sorry you had a wait this evening. Our pick up time was an hour and 15 minutes. Our system only goes to an hour for pick up and delivery. We were sending deliveries as they were coming out of the oven. We will learn from this and turn off online ordering when times go over the hour so customers will know a more accurate time when we are busy. We thank you for your business and want you happy. We would be happy give you a credit and make your order for another night for you. Thank you for reaching out.

Thanks! Your answer is awaiting moderation.

Thanks! Your question is awaiting moderation.

Related Places