Serenity Bay Cottages

Suzanna Ramos

It was gorgeous 😍 The owner had cameras outside which is understandable but I kept getting an eerie feeling I was being watched inside. Probably not, but couldn't shake that feeling after she sent me a text about the door being ajar.

F. L. Stockman

Our 2-day trip to Matlacha and Pine Island was a delight, partly because our choice to forego the chain hotels and try Serenity Bay. Sharon had great suggestions on where to eat and made us feel as if we were staying with a friend. We found room #2 to be attractive and the perfect size for the 2 of us. The A/C was quiet and very effective, and we lacked nothing. Our 2 hours enjoying the bay in the provided kayaks was a highlight. Do bring mosquito repellent if you enjoy the sunset by the fire pit as we did, as mosquitos are a fact of life in Summer after the sun goes down. We look forward to seeing more of the area with Serenity Bay as our HQ!

cindy lee

I rented this place for my daughter and the owner couldn't have been more amicable. The room was clean and homey and beautifully situated on the water.

Joe Higgins

We stayed 2 nights and really enjoyed it. Clean rooms and a very nice view of the water. Peaceful sitting out in the evening. Owners are very accommodating.