Old Fashioned Ice Cream

Category: Ice cream shop

Address: 1025 Straight Path, West Babylon, NY 11704, USA

Phone: +16316693020

Opening hours

Sunday: 12–10PM

Monday: 12–10PM

Tuesday: 12–10PM

Wednesday: 12–10PM

Thursday: 12–10PM

Friday: 12–10PM

Saturday: 12–10PM

Reviews

DJDEAN98

Sep 25, 2022

This is such amazing ice cream! Better than any other ice cream place! The service is amazing, the ice cream hit different, and the people working there are amazing! Worth the travel AND the wait ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

Paul Gayle

Sep 23, 2022

Friendly staff and delicious ice cream

Dawn Cain

Sep 12, 2022

Great Ice cream...many flavors and options like sundaes and milkshakes. Little pricey

Yin Fer

Sep 6, 2022

I love this store. They are currently closed till further notice due to a car crashing into their store today 9/5. Please find out in advance if you can go.. maybe give them a call. Tried to inform Google that they are closed until further notice but it didn't publish.

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.

Questions & Answers

Do you Do delivery?

Yaneli and The fam | Oct 3, 2020
Ms. B. | Oct 3, 2020

No they don't but it's worth the ride

Read More

Do they offer almond milk or alternative milk options?

Nicole | Oct 3, 2021
Old Fashioned Ice Cream | Oct 3, 2021

Hi Nicole! We usually have a NonDairy Soft Serve Option. We carry Froconut Chocolate which is a non dairy ice cream made with coconut milk or be Dole Whip (non dairy). This week we have pineapple dole whip. Flavors change weekly - You can call 631-669-3020 and we’ll let you know what non dairy option we have. Or follow us on Instagram or Facebook for more updates. Thank you 😊🍦

Read More

Do they sell frozen yogurt

Norma Varley | Oct 4, 2019
Old Fashioned Ice Cream | Oct 4, 2019

Hello Norma & Thank you for your inquiry. And hello Tyrone - thank you for answering. I am happy to let you know that we currently carry vanilla peanut butter chip yogurt - it is a hard vanilla yogurt with chocolate & peanut butter chips throughout. In addition we are bringing back frozen yogurt! We will have soft vanilla yogurt starting this Saturday. We hope you stop by to see us. We offer delicious soft serve ice cream, frozen yogurt and Dole Whip (non dairy, gluten free, cholesterol-free, kosher frozen dessert). We also have over 40 flavors of homemade hard ice cream & Italian ices.

Read More

Thanks! Your answer is awaiting moderation.

Thanks! Your question is awaiting moderation.

Related Places