Il Mulino

Category: Italian restaurant in New York

Address: 86 W 3rd St, New York, NY 10012, USA

Phone: +12126733783

Opening hours

Sunday: 4–9PM

Monday: 5–10:30PM

Tuesday: 5–10:30PM

Wednesday: 5–10:30PM

Thursday: 5–10:30PM

Friday: 5–10:30PM

Saturday: 5–10:30PM

Reviews

T A

Oct 3, 2022

This place is extremely low class. I don't know who they fooled/bribed to get a "fine dining" description because it's awful and I will never go back. The place is very small and I was sat at a larger round table. However, because they jammed it in in the corner, it didn't leave much room between my chair and the bar table where someone was seated and a two-top by the window. Through the course of the meal, a waiter trying to get by without saying a word to me just started pushing my chair in while I'm seated on it to squeeze by. A few minutes later, the manager suggested I move to the chair over as one of our party ended up leaving early. That made sense so I obliged. That other chair however is by the waiter station and not long passed before a waiter came by and said I was blocking him from accessing the drawer and asked me to move again. It was so simply ridiculous if they're not trying to jam all these cramped seats into one space, they wouldn't have this problem. How could you keep on asking a diner to move and move and move again? Then the rest of the night, the phone on that waiter station one foot away rang by my ear, constantly. "Fine dining" lol. To add insult to injury, the food was so bad. The caesar salad was tasteless. The lettuce was not crisp or cold, the dressing had no flavor, no anchovy or egg to speak of, just bland. The croutons seemed stale. The kitchen made us another one and they sent another tasteless bowl right out. The pastas are not that good. The steak is so average. The manager came out to say sorry his waiter had asked me to move again but he really did not make much of an effort. All this restaurant did was set up a table for a miserable dining experience. This is not it, guys. Dear god.

Johnny Tramonte

Sep 21, 2022

Food was good, albeit a bit overly salty. But the only down side was it was way too dark, had to use a flashlight to see the menu.

Georges Peillon

Aug 20, 2022

A scam. The servers are apparently friendly but it's better to make you pay a salty bill! €30-40 for a plate of pasta, which is salty, the chef must have dropped a salt shaker. And the icing on the cake: we run after you in the street to find out if you paid!!! Place to avoid!

Steven

Aug 17, 2022

Place is alright, all the original waitstaff and kitchen staff is no longer there, heard from the waiter the original staff is in LIC, il falco, place will always stand for their old school vibes, bruschetta, parm, zucchini, etc. overpriced too

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.

Questions & Answers

Are kids allowed ?

Basma Faisal | Oct 3, 2018
F D | Oct 3, 2018

Yes. The food is extraordinary.

Read More

How expensive is this place? Please give an example. Thank you!

Logan Marino | Oct 3, 2019
Bill Simo | Oct 3, 2019

It's priced Right for the great food you will be eating. It's family style they feed you from the moment you sit down. I've been going there roughly 25 years and have never been disappointed. I Highly recommend this place!

Read More

which Il Mulino restaurant is closest to The Chatwal Hotel, 130 W. 44th street? Thanks

Donna Flower | Oct 3, 2019
ZOLAR VISION | Oct 3, 2019

61st street And Madison Avenue

Large toaster rack— will it hold a 25 lb turkey?

George Sick | Oct 3, 2019
ZOLAR VISION | Oct 3, 2019

I would not risk it

Does Il Mulino take credit cards?

George Rozansky | Oct 3, 2018
Placido Hernandez | Oct 3, 2018

Yes, they do take your credit card.

Read More

Do you take credit cards

FRANK CARPIN | Oct 3, 2018
Carla Wilkins | Oct 3, 2018

Yes, but I would check on Discover

Read More

Thanks! Your answer is awaiting moderation.

Thanks! Your question is awaiting moderation.

Related Places