Paisano's Italian Bakery

Category: Bakery in Sarasota, Florida

Address: 2732 Stickney Point Rd, Sarasota, FL 34231, USA

Phone: +19419268422

Opening hours

Sunday: Closed

Monday: 9AM–6PM

Tuesday: 9AM–6PM

Wednesday: 9AM–6PM

Thursday: 9AM–6PM

Friday: 9AM–6PM

Saturday: 9AM–6PM

Reviews

Notary Florida

Sep 21, 2022

Tomato Pie was great; as well as, the bread & desserts. However, if I were to judge the cleanliness of the kitchen based on the restroom, the score would be 2.5 or less.

Crystal (Chris)

Sep 20, 2022

Awesome pastry

Steve S

Sep 14, 2022

Great bakery with friendly staff.

Don Goodenow

Aug 30, 2022

Just an excellent bakery

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.

Questions & Answers

Do you make zeppole on March 15

Karen LaGioia | Oct 3, 2019
Lynn | Oct 3, 2019

Yummy!!!

Read More

Do you deliver within Florida? I see RI pizza strips!

Susan P | Dec 6, 2021
Lauren Pross | Dec 6, 2021

Local delivery is available 34231and door dash

What are the Covid safety practices like here?

Anonymous | Oct 2, 2022
john laprairie | Oct 2, 2021

Very good. Every employee was masked and gloved.

Read More

do you sell any sugar free products

Azurdi Angelo | Oct 3, 2018
John Broadfoot | Oct 3, 2018

I believe that they do.

Do they offer keto selections?

Rebecca Hammitt | May 5, 2022
lsabel Rivera | May 5, 2022

I don't think so call them

Read More

Do you actually make Italian Rum Cake? Nobody here in Florida seems to know what that is...

george parmer | Oct 2, 2021
Beverly Scandariato | Oct 2, 2021

I was there yesterday. Saw some cut in individual squares. Ingredients were I think rum, sponge cake, and puff pastry? It looked delicious. Everything I have tried is amazing.

Do they sell pizza crusts?

Martin Heid | Oct 2, 2021
Christine Savage | Oct 2, 2021

Yes they do sell pizza dough. Was there last week. Love the store.

Read More

Do you make Tiramisu

Corrine French | Oct 2, 2020
Brian M | Oct 2, 2020

The best around

Read More

Can you make a wedding cake for 75?

marjorie dupree | Oct 2, 2020
Sharon Tucker | Oct 2, 2020

Paisano's isn't a great place to get a wedding cake. I was very disappointed. I had a number of cakes made and none of them were any good. Go to Mama G's on 41 near the airport. She makes beautiful cakes and is reasonable. She has a lot of homemade goodness. Very nice family. She makes birthday cakes and many pastries. I am sure you won't be disappointed. She is in where Captain Brian restaurant is. Right next door.

Do you have pistachio and strawberry leaf cookies?

Amanda Corrigan | Oct 3, 2019
Diane Schertzer | Oct 3, 2019

Maybe, probably, best to call. I've seen that they do special orders too.

Read More

do you carry siesta key rum cakes

Joanne Cisler | Oct 3, 2019
Linda Malgioglio | Oct 3, 2019

No. This is an italian pastry shop galore. Italian cookies and italian bread baked fresh.

Read More

Do you sell Paczki cream filled ( Not Boston creme) .

nancy sekrenes | Oct 3, 2019
john laprairie | Oct 3, 2019

Actually, they do sell cream filled Pazki, along with raspberry, lemon, chocolate, chocolate buttercream, vanilla buttercream, the list is endless.

Read More

Do you sell dinner rolls?

Terry Bowen | Oct 3, 2019
Linda Malgioglio | Oct 3, 2019

At this point in time I would call. Last year they made dinner rolls for the holidays. Normally they bake italian bread and the smallest choice was a hoagie roll. Their soft crust italian bread loaf is out of this world.

Read More

Do you make Pumpernickle bread?

Suzanne Faircloth | Oct 3, 2019
Tom Wroble | Oct 3, 2019

No, it's an Italian Bakery.

Read More

DO YOU MAKE CHOCOLATE PIES?

Patti Koch | Oct 3, 2019
jean-luc casano | Oct 3, 2019

Yes

Read More

Do they sell pignoli cookies?

Laura Mancinelli | Oct 3, 2018
Hernando castañeda | Oct 3, 2018

Yes they do

Read More

We are trying to find authentic Tuscan bread. Do you sell it?

William Hard | Oct 3, 2018
George Thaler | Oct 3, 2018

Great Italian bakery!

Read More

Do you sell St Joes day Pastries

Joe Catania | Oct 3, 2018
Christine OConnell | Oct 3, 2018

Yes,they do( at this time of the year) and around holiday time.

Do you make trays of lasagna?

diane vargetto | Oct 3, 2018
Gina H | Oct 3, 2018

I don't see why not. I've seen individual servings of lasagna so I'm thinking that with enough notice, they should be able to prepare a full tray without a problem.

Read More

Was Paisano's bakery, in Redwood City, CA at one time years ago. and does the bakery make rum cakes?

Becky M | Oct 3, 2018
Jeff Fox | Oct 3, 2018

I don't think so and yes they do

Looking for a true bread baker of CRispy Crusty bread.

Dalony Cutting | Oct 3, 2018
Artie Wray | Oct 3, 2018

Paisano's has great bread ... crunchy outside & fluffy inside. Just get there early ... they sell out fast.

Read More

Thanks! Your answer is awaiting moderation.

Thanks! Your question is awaiting moderation.

Related Places