I Love NY Pizza

Wende W

The amount of burnt junk baked into the crust made the pizza taste awful. It even smelled bad. Seems easy to clean the screens off before putting more dough on them. Gonna throw the leftovers away.

Alan McRea Jr

Best NY pizza in Wilmington. Some of the best pizza anywhere in fact. Right now during the pandemic, they do not let anyone in. Ever. And if you don't have a mask on, they won't even come to the window. I LOVE that. Clean, cheap, good.

Rachel Beverly

Definitely the best pizza in town and I love the girl who works the window, she's always friendly and says hello even if I'm just walking by her order window. I e ordered from there so much the lady at the window know I love parm and red pepper flakes and just hands them to me with my pizza. Good food great people

Katelyn Rivenbark

I have had this pizza sober and drunk and pizza is amazing. It feels so good to eat food from local business here in town. The employee, especially Ellie, always greet me with the most warmest of smiles and happiest of hellos. The pizza taste the best when Ellie is working because I know she puts a labor love into every pizza she makes. I personally recommend the pepperoni and mushroom, but if you do not like mushrooms then get the pepperoni and sausage or margarita pizza if you are a vegetarian. If you are looking for a good pizza and don't mind the wait in the evening (it's a popular place at night but I promise the wait is worth it), then go here, support the local ILM community, and get to know the badass people who make the best got dang pizza in town.