Aunt Cookies Sub Shop

Al Menard

The best sub shop in Geneseo by far! This place has been around for over 30 years and has always made amazing sandwiches!

Melissa Sherwood’s

My daughter goes to SUNY Geneseo and we were heading out for a hike and stopped at this cute little sub shop. Everything was delicious. The fresh baked rolls were delicious and so were the cookies. Looking forward to our next visit.

Patrick Murphy

FANTASTIC sub. I wish my companions had told me that this place makes its own bread as we had limited time and had to sort of wolf it down but it was delicious and the bread was terrific. Definitely be aware that it's going to take an extra 10 minutes or so more than places that don't do fresh bread but it is totally worth it

Richard K

I was a first time visitor to the Central New York college town of Geneseo on Monday September 9, 2019. I was hungry and it was lunchtime so I went exploring this charming village looking for some food. I had just walked out of the pizza place across the street because the music was obnoxiously loud and then I saw this sandwich shop. Apparently this business is the oldest one in town. The restaurant was quiet and comfortable. I had an half Italian sub, toasted with yellow mustard. Delicious. The staff was friendly and my Discover Card was accepted. I recommend Aunt Cookies when in Geneseo NY.