Goodfellas Pizza

Aaliah Lanzetta

The cashier was amazing very pleasant and a warming experience the pizza was made to the exact way I asked for it highly impressed I will definitely be coming back

Mat Carlton

The pizza the best just like Real NY pizza I recommend too anyone who loves good Italian pizza

Rae J

Sadly I was extremely disappointed and we can start that I spent 19$ on the lunch deal which is 2 slices of pizza and a drink and I ordered a antipasto salad on the side with extra dressing. I’m not certain if it was because the pizza was sitting on the counter far too long before preheated or if like everyone else the quality of ingredients are depleting due to increase of prices. The sauce had absolutely no taste and the cheese was chunky and overly chewy, but also was very bland. The crust was okay but was very very thin for a New York style pizza which is all what makes me think maybe the shift was due to ingredients and not necessarily effort. My second complaint was the salad. I would say maybe 30% of the lettuce was brown or starting to brown and the entire salad was very very wet. They definitely put about half has many pepperonis (literally gave me 8 small pepperonis for a large salad) as they used to. I understand that products are down but maybe increase the price a little because this was extremely disappointing. I’d rather spend maybe 2-3$ more and get better quality than being mad I spent $20. I couldn’t even just take the cheese off the pizza and eat it, which is what I usually do in this sort of case. I’m disappointed. I don’t like making negative reviews, but this is more so the owner knows the level of his service in case they weren’t aware. I left photos of the thinness of the pizza, the lack of meat and the wet/browning lettuce for reference. I gave them 2 stars because the cashier was nice, the store seems clean and I don’t think it’s intentional bad service. If seen I would love to discuss how my opinion can be fixed or maybe get another order/refund. Thanks.

William Karger

Great place to order pizza good food good environment