Old School N.Y. Pizza

Matt Clark

It is pretty good pizza but the reason for the 1 star is because on 6/18 I placed an online order. They called and said it would be 25 minutes. I arrived 40 minutes later and they had not even started on it! It was a group of high school kids running things that night it appears and they laughed about it and said “oops we don’t know how we missed this one.” I had to wait another 20 minutes and all that was shared were laughs and teenagers goofing off in the kitchen while I waited for my order. Completely unacceptable.

LJ

Id give this place 10 stars if Google allowed. Pizza is fantastic! Staff is outstanding! Just a superb place overall! We dine in at least once a month. And we've also ordered 13 pizzas for a bday party. Pizzas were ready on time, hot, and ready to go.

Ben Seay

I had 2 slices a pepperoni, they were out when I arrived so I waited 10 min to get fresh slices out of the oven. Im from philly this pizza is the closest thing ive had to real northern east coast pizza since ive lived in the ville. Red sauce is tomato fresh pop kick to it, crust has a crunch, cheese is stringy and good. If u dont like a flop in ur pizza slices tell them u want ur slices or pie well done. I personally will be asking for well done when i go back.

Bart Marshall

Their pizza is amazing! If you want to get in and out for lunch, they have it pre-made and ready for you in 5 minutes. If you want more of a sit-down dining experience, their Norton Commons location is great! It also doesn't hurt that the bartender makes the most amazing Kentucky old fashioned!